August 4, 2025: Submarine acquisition of the Philippines may have gone out of favor under BBM, as per a former Admiral of the Philippine Navy
The retired Rear Admiral Rommel Jude Ong, a former Vice Commander of the Philippine Navy (PN) recently wrote for the Rappler (yuck) News Publication stating his Observation that the acquisition of Submarines may have gone out of favor already under this Administration of Bong Bong Marcos (BBM).
He is basing this Opinion on a recent Interview of Defense Secretary Gilberto Teodoro who said that the PN should look at Unmanned Systems or Drones as an Alternative instead. Ong argued in his Article for keeping the Submarine buy, but in the End says that if the Department of National Defense (DND) really wants to scrap the Program, then it should do so soon, and officially.
Here is the Link to the Article at the Rappler Website: https://www.rappler.com/voices/thought-leaders/opinion-navy-submarine-program-challenges/
MY THOUGHTS:
I have always been a Proponent for the PN acquiring Subs based on the Lessons of the Falklands War where Argentina’s Submarines were the only ones left fighting the Naval Forces of the United Kingdom (UK) after the UK’s own Submarine sank Argentina’s biggest Battleship early in the War.
That forced almost the entire Argentinian Navy to run and stay in Port, leaving only their Subs to fight the UK. Vietnam also as of now has their Submarines as the “Tip of the Spear” of their Navy, they don’t have Surface Combatants that are larger than 103 meters, smaller than our Jose Rizal class Frigates.
But then again, I do understand the Issues with acquiring Submarines, particularly the Fact that it takes too long for them to be built. All of the Manufacturers that are offering their Subs to the PN that I have read always said it will take them around eight Years to build two Subs.
For that same amount of time, you can already build at least twice that number of Frigates already, or around four. And at less cost also, as the Frigates we are getting costs are only around Usd 300-400 million each, while the Subs costs around Usd 500 million to Usd 1 billion each.
The stunning success of Land-based Cruise Missiles and Unmanned Surface Vehicles (USV) by Ukraine against the powerful Russian Navy in their ongoing War also seem to indicate that those Weapons will be better Cost-Effective Alternatives to the much more expensive Submarines.
In Fact I have seen some American Defense Articles talking about getting these USVs instead specifically for the Philippines, so that will just strengthen the Argument of their acquisition to our Defense Secretary since he is very much Pro-United States (US) already.
This will also help the BBM Government spend less since it seems that its Php 2 trillion Modernization Program for the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) is mostly just Hype, it has not allocated sure Funding for the acquisitions any more than what the Administration of former President Rodrigo Duterte has.
The BBM Government can now say, “we’re not buying Submarines not because we can’t afford to, but because there are cheaper and effective Alternatives like Cruise Missiles and USVs which are available”, ahem, char, LOL.
April 16, 2025: Fincantieri and TKMS offers non-Magnetic Hulls, Naval Base and Italian Navy support to Philippines with their U212 NFS Submarines
Both Fincantieri SpA and ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems (TKMS) both released Press Releases on their own Websites containing a bit more Details of their offer of the Type 212 Near Future Submarine (NFS) or U212 NFS to the Philippines, and I thought I just needed to note it down for future Reference. So here is what they are offering:
* With Air Independent Propulsion (AIP)
* Use of "Amanox" non-Magnetic Steel, probably for the Hull
* Training, Doctrine and Logistics Support from the Italian Navy
* A new Naval Base, probably for the Submarines
You can read about the Press Release on the Fincantieri Website: https://www.fincantieri.com/en/media/press-releases/2025/fincantieri-and-thyssenkrupp-marine-systems-partner-for-philippines-submarines-project/
MY NOTES:
Surprise-surpise, they are indeed now offering the non-Magnetic Hull Feature which was previously not allowed for Export. As per the "Interwebs", Amanox is an Alloy known not only for its non-magnetic Properties, but also for its high Corrosion Resistance, making it ideal as Material for Submarine Hulls.
The U212 is about the only Submarine Model in active Service right now which is using a non-magnetic Hull, making it very hard to detect by Magnetic Mines and the Magnetic Anomaly Detector (MAD) used by some Anti-Submarine Warfare (ASW) Aircraft.
The U212 uses Hydrogen Fuel Cells for its AIP which allows it to stay underwater without using Snorkels to recharge its Batteries for up to three Weeks, or 21 Days, and its Armaments consist of up to a maximum of 13 mix of Torpedoes and Missiles.
Note though that as per the Information released by South Korea (SK) a couple of Years ago, they are offering an additional Type 209-based Design Submarine if the Philippines buys two, sort of like a “Buy two, Take one” Deal.
So the Philippines will have some hard Decisions to make when choosing which Submarine to get soon, get more older Design-based Subs, or get newer ones with some unique Features like the U212.
SOURCES: